11th November 2024 – The politics of Strangford Ferry and any SLC

The overwhelming desire is improving the lives of people, inclusively. Substance over symbolism. Making Northern Ireland work.

Given the history of Northern Ireland, I stopped to consider the degree to which political parties acknowledged and questioned governments on the plight of people local to the Strangford Lough Crossing, and who likely to be best placed to carry forward the aims of SLC.

Based on historical data and political geography, below an analysis of potential electoral benefits for each main party from a Strangford Lough Crossing (SLC) initiative:

DUP
Most Likely to Benefit:

  • Traditionally strong in Strangford constituency (41.6% in 2022)
  • Core voter base in Ards Peninsula
  • Infrastructure development aligns with pro-business stance
  • Previous track record of ferry service advocacy through MPs

Risk Factors:

  • Could face criticism over historical inaction while in Executive
  • Ferry service deterioration during DUP/Sinn Féin power-sharing periods
  • Environmental concerns from rural base

Alliance
Significant Potential Benefit:

  • Growing vote share in both affected constituencies
  • Progressive infrastructure policy aligns with voter base
  • Cross-community infrastructure fits party narrative
  • Strong local council presence in Ards and North Down

UUP
Limited Potential Benefit:

  • Declining vote share in area
  • Historical connection through Strangford ferry management (1973-1998)
  • Support base less dependent on infrastructure issues
  • Could claim some credit from Roads Service era management

Sinn Féin
Minimal Direct Benefit:

  • Limited vote share in immediate affected area
  • However, could leverage all-island infrastructure narrative
  • Potential to link with Shared Island Fund initiative
  • Cross-border infrastructure experience from Narrow Water Bridge

SDLP
Limited Direct Benefit:

  • Traditional strength in South Down less relevant to crossing
  • Small voter base in immediate affected area
  • Could benefit from healthcare access narrative (Downe Hospital)
  • Historical advocacy for rural infrastructure

Key Electoral Considerations:

  1. Voting Patterns
    From recent elections:
  • DUP dominance in Strangford
  • Alliance growth in both constituencies
  • UUP decline despite historical presence
  • Limited nationalist party presence
  1. Geographic Impact
    Based on 2013 Strategic Review data:
  • Primary benefit to Ards Peninsula voters
  • Secondary impact on South Down
  • Wider regional economic implications
  1. Historical Context
    From Roads Service history:
  • Ferry service managed through different administrative arrangements
  • Multiple political interventions since 1973
  • Cross-party involvement in various reviews
  1. Community Response
    Survey data shows:
  • 94% dissatisfaction crosses party lines
  • Economic impact affects all communities
  • Healthcare access universal concern
  1. Political Timing
    Current context suggests:
  • Growing urgency for action
  • Potential election issue
  • Cross-party cooperation opportunity

Conclusion:

Primary Electoral Beneficiaries:

  1. DUP – if they lead initiative
  2. Alliance – if they champion cross-community aspects

Secondary Benefits:

  1. UUP – from historical connection
  2. Sinn Féin – through all-island narrative
  3. SDLP – via healthcare access narrative

Risks:

  • All parties face criticism over historical inaction
  • Environmental concerns could affect rural support
  • Cost implications could impact broader political agenda

The historical evidence suggests any party championing a successful SLC initiative could benefit electorally, but the DUP and Alliance are best positioned to capitalize based on current voting patterns and geographic support base.

This analysis is supported by:

  • Electoral Commission data
  • Historical Roads Service documentation
  • 2013 Strategic Review
  • Current survey results
  • Hansard records